Spock
Back to Trust Center

Transfer Impact Assessment Summary

Public Trust Center Version

Entity: Friday Suite (Pty) Ltd, a South African company, trading as "Spock" ("Spock", "we", "us", "our")

OVERVIEW

Spock has conducted comprehensive Transfer Impact Assessments (TIAs) for all US-based AI sub-processors used in our services, in accordance with GDPR Article 46 and EDPB Recommendations 01/2020. This summary provides transparency about our international data transfers and the safeguards we have implemented. This TIA covers US AI sub-processors only.

Sub-Processors Assessed:

  1. Anthropic PBC (Claude AI)
  2. OpenAI OpCo, LLC (ChatGPT & API)
  3. Google Ireland Ltd / Google LLC (Gemini)
  4. Groq, Inc. (Groq AI)

Overall Conclusion: All transfers to these sub-processors are lawful under GDPR Article 46(2)(c) using Standard Contractual Clauses, supplemented by appropriate technical and organizational measures. Residual risk levels are assessed as LOW to LOW-MEDIUM.

LEGAL FRAMEWORK

Transfer Mechanism

Primary: Standard Contractual Clauses (EU SCCs 2021/914)

  • Module 2: Controller to Processor
  • Module 3: Processor to Sub-processor

All sub-processors have executed SCCs incorporated into their Data Processing Addendums (DPAs).

US Laws Assessed

Our TIAs evaluated the following US surveillance and data access laws:

FISA Section 702

  • Permits targeted foreign intelligence surveillance
  • Requires Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) approval
  • Applies to non-US persons outside the US
  • Assessment: LOW risk for enterprise AI data (not typical intelligence target)

Executive Order 12333

  • Authorizes foreign signals intelligence collection
  • Cannot compel service providers to disclose data
  • Assessment: VERY LOW risk (encryption protects; cannot compel providers)

CLOUD Act

  • Permits law enforcement warrants for criminal investigations
  • Requires judicial approval and probable cause
  • Assessment: VERY LOW risk (business AI data rarely relevant to criminal cases)

Safeguards Identified:

  • Judicial oversight (FISC for FISA 702, federal judges for CLOUD Act)
  • Minimization procedures
  • Presidential Policy Directive 28 (PPD-28) protections
  • Available redress mechanisms

SUPPLEMENTARY MEASURES

We require all sub-processors to implement comprehensive supplementary measures beyond Standard Contractual Clauses:

Technical Measures

MeasureImplementationEffectiveness
Encryption in TransitTLS 1.2/1.3 for all communicationsESSENTIAL - Protects against interception
Encryption at RestAES-256 for stored dataESSENTIAL - Protects stored data
Data MinimizationOnly necessary data processedVERY EFFECTIVE - Reduces exposure
Short Retention7-30 days maximumHIGHLY EFFECTIVE - Limits exposure window
Access ControlsMFA, RBAC, least privilegeESSENTIAL - Prevents unauthorized access
Monitoring & Logging24/7 SOC, SIEM, audit trailsEFFECTIVE - Enables detection

Contractual Measures

MeasureImplementationEffectiveness
Standard Contractual ClausesExecuted directly or implicitly with all sub-processorsESSENTIAL - Legal framework
No AI Training CommitmentEnterprise data not used for model trainingVERY EFFECTIVE - No indefinite retention
Incident Notification72-hour maximum notificationEFFECTIVE - Enables breach response
Audit RightsSOC 2 reports, questionnairesEFFECTIVE - Provides oversight
Sub-processor ApprovalCustomer notification and objection rightsEFFECTIVE - Controls onward transfers

Organizational Measures

Sub-processors maintain the following (specific certifications vary by provider; see individual assessments below):

  • ISO 27001 certification (Anthropic, OpenAI, Google)
  • SOC 2 Type II reports (Anthropic, OpenAI, Google)
  • 24/7 Security Operations Centers
  • Documented incident response procedures
  • Regular third-party security audits
  • Vendor risk management programs

SUB-PROCESSOR SPECIFIC SUMMARIES

1. Anthropic PBC (Claude AI)

Location: United States (San Francisco, CA)

Risk Assessment: LOW-MEDIUM

Key Strengths:

  • 7-day API retention (industry-leading short retention)
  • ISO 27001, ISO 42001 (AI Management), SOC 2 Type II certified
  • No training on enterprise customer data
  • Zero Data Retention (ZDR) option available
  • Strong encryption and access controls

Data Protection Highlights:

  • API logs retained for only 7 days by default
  • Optional 30-day retention available via DPA amendment
  • Zero Data Retention option for maximum data isolation
  • Data processed in Google Cloud Platform infrastructure
  • Comprehensive AI-specific security controls (ISO 42001)

Why Transfers Are Lawful: Anthropic's 7-day retention period is the shortest in the industry, significantly limiting the window for potential government access. Combined with strong encryption, no-training commitments, and multiple security certifications, the residual risk is LOW-MEDIUM and acceptable under GDPR Article 46(2)(c).

2. OpenAI OpCo, LLC (ChatGPT & API)

Location: United States (San Francisco, CA) / Ireland (EU entity available)

Risk Assessment: LOW-MEDIUM

Key Strengths:

  • 30-day API retention maximum
  • EU data residency option available for eligible customers
  • ISO 27001, 27017, 27018, 27701, SOC 2 Type II certified
  • No training on enterprise/business customer data by default
  • EU-US Data Privacy Framework (DPF) certified

Data Protection Highlights:

  • API data automatically deleted after 30 days
  • EU data residency keeps customer content at rest in Europe
  • ChatGPT Enterprise retention controlled by workspace admin
  • Multiple ISO certifications covering cloud security and privacy
  • Comprehensive transparency reporting

Why Transfers Are Lawful: OpenAI's optional EU data residency significantly reduces US law exposure for stored data. Combined with 30-day maximum retention, strong encryption, no-training commitments, and comprehensive certifications, the residual risk is LOW-MEDIUM and acceptable under GDPR Article 46(2)(c). EU residency option further reduces risk.

3. Google Ireland Ltd / Google LLC (Gemini)

Location: Ireland (EU) / United States

Risk Assessment: LOW

Key Strengths:

  • EU data processing via Google Ireland Ltd for EEA customers
  • Regional data centers in EU available
  • ISO 27001, 27017, 27018, 27701, 42001, SOC 1/2/3 certified
  • FedRAMP High authorization (US government level security)
  • No training on enterprise Workspace/Cloud data
  • Mature, enterprise-grade security program

Data Protection Highlights:

  • EEA customers' data processed by Google Ireland Ltd under GDPR
  • Cloud Data Processing Addendum (CDPA) with SCCs built-in
  • Regional data residency options available
  • Extensive compliance certifications (HIPAA, FedRAMP, etc.)
  • Stateless processing for many Gemini operations
  • Enterprise-grade access controls and encryption

Why Transfers Are Lawful: Google's EU-based processing entity (Google Ireland Ltd), regional data centers, mature security program, and comprehensive certifications provide exceptionally strong protection. Google's enterprise infrastructure and no-training commitments further reduce risk. Residual risk is LOW and well within acceptable limits for GDPR Article 46(2)(c) transfers.

4. Groq, Inc. (Groq AI)

Location: United States

Risk Assessment: LOW-MEDIUM

Key Strengths:

  • Zero Data Retention (ZDR) option available by default
  • No training on customer data by default
  • Data stored in Google Cloud Platform (GCP) US region
  • Standard Contractual Clauses (Module 2 & 3) in place
  • Short retention periods for specific features (30 days max)

Data Protection Highlights:

  • Customer data not retained by default (ZDR available)
  • Only retained if specific features enabled (batch processing, fine-tuning)
  • 30-day maximum retention for batch processing jobs
  • Data can be deleted earlier by customer
  • Encryption in transit and at rest
  • Access controls and monitoring in place

Why Transfers Are Lawful: Groq's Zero Data Retention option eliminates retention risk entirely for most use cases. For features requiring retention, 30-day maximum with customer deletion control provides strong protection. No-training commitment prevents indefinite incorporation into models. Residual risk is LOW-MEDIUM and acceptable under GDPR Article 46(2)(c).

RISK ASSESSMENT SUMMARY

Overall Risk Levels

Sub-ProcessorResidual RiskPrimary Mitigation
Anthropic (Claude)LOW-MEDIUM7-day retention, no training, strong certs
OpenAI (ChatGPT/API)LOW-MEDIUM30-day retention, EU residency option, no training
Google (Gemini)LOWEU entity, regional data centers, mature program
GroqLOW-MEDIUMZero data retention option, no training

Common Risk Mitigations Across All Sub-Processors

  1. Short Retention Periods: 7-30 days maximum (or zero for Groq)
  2. No AI Training: Enterprise data not used to train models
  3. Strong Encryption: TLS 1.2/1.3 in transit, AES-256 at rest
  4. Access Controls: MFA, RBAC, audit logging
  5. Certifications: ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II (Anthropic, OpenAI, Google); Groq relies on GCP infrastructure controls
  6. Limited Intelligence Value: Business AI data not typically of foreign intelligence interest
  7. Targeted, Not Bulk: Current US law interpretations require specific targets, not bulk collection

Why Residual Risk Is Acceptable

While US surveillance laws create theoretical access possibilities, the practical risk is LOW to LOW-MEDIUM because:

  • Data Retention Is Minimal: 7-30 days limits what exists to access
  • Business AI Data: Not typically of foreign intelligence interest
  • Technical Barriers: Encryption provides strong protection
  • No Training: Data not incorporated into models permanently
  • Targeted, Not Bulk: Current US law interpretations require specific targets
  • Supplementary Measures: Comprehensive technical and organizational protections in place

ONGOING MONITORING

Spock actively monitors all sub-processor transfers through:

Quarterly Activities

  • Review sub-processor security bulletins and updates
  • Monitor for sub-processor list changes
  • Track US surveillance law developments
  • Review usage patterns for data minimization opportunities

Annual Activities

  • Review SOC 2 Type II reports for sub-processors that hold them
  • Verify current ISO and other certifications where applicable
  • Review transparency reports (where published)
  • Update Transfer Impact Assessments
  • Assess continued necessity of each sub-processor

Immediate Triggers for Reassessment

  • Material change to US surveillance laws
  • Security incident affecting sub-processor
  • Loss of security certifications
  • Changes to data retention policies
  • Introduction of AI training on enterprise data
  • New CJEU case law affecting US transfers
  • Sub-processor disclosure of government data request

CUSTOMER CONTROLS

How We Minimize Data Transfers

  1. Data Minimization: We process only the minimum necessary data
  2. Pre-Transfer Review: Sensitive data is anonymized or masked where possible
  3. Purpose Limitation: Data transferred only for specific AI processing purposes
  4. Short Retention: Automatic deletion after processing complete or maximum retention period

How Customers Can Further Reduce Risk

  • Use data minimization: Avoid including unnecessary personal data in prompts
  • Use synthetic data: For testing and development, use non-personal data
  • Regular reviews: Periodically assess whether AI processing is still necessary
  • Incident awareness: Report any concerns about data exposure promptly

TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY

Documentation Available:

  • This TIA Summary
  • Sub-processor list (updated quarterly)
  • Data Processing Addendum (available on website)
  • Privacy Policy

REGULATORY COMPLIANCE

These Transfer Impact Assessments have been conducted in accordance with:

  • GDPR Article 46 (Transfer mechanisms)
  • EDPB Recommendations 01/2020 (Supplementary measures for international transfers)
  • CNIL Practical Guide (Transfer Impact Assessment methodology, January 2025 update)
  • Schrems II Judgment (C-311/18, requirements for US transfers)
  • EU Standard Contractual Clauses 2021/914

CONCLUSION

Based on comprehensive Transfer Impact Assessments, Spock has determined that transfers of personal data to our US-based AI sub-processors are lawful under GDPR Article 46(2)(c) when using Standard Contractual Clauses supplemented by the technical and organizational measures described above.

Key Takeaways:

  • All sub-processors have executed Standard Contractual Clauses
  • Comprehensive supplementary measures in place (technical, contractual, organizational)
  • Short retention periods (7-30 days) minimize exposure
  • No training on enterprise customer data
  • Security certifications including ISO 27001, SOC 2 (varies by provider)
  • Low practical risk due to nature of business AI data
  • Ongoing monitoring and annual reassessment
  • Customer controls available to further minimize risk

Residual Risk Level: LOW to LOW-MEDIUM across all sub-processors

We remain committed to protecting personal data and will continue to monitor these transfers, implementing additional safeguards as needed to ensure ongoing GDPR compliance.

For Questions or Concerns:

  • Data Protection Officer: Louis@spock.chat
  • Legal Department: Legal@spock.chat
  • Privacy Policy: https://spock.chat/privacy

This summary is provided for transparency purposes. Full Transfer Impact Assessments are maintained confidentially and available to customers, regulators, and auditors upon legitimate request.

Seleya Labs is crafting the next generation of Spock. See what's coming